Liang WeiweiPRC counsel · Shanghai
Case notes

Eight files, described without names.

Composite notes drawn from matters handled since 2019. No client, company, court or tribunal is identified; figures are given as magnitudes; outcomes are described as procedural positions, not as results achieved.

All matters are anonymised under client confidentiality. Nothing here is a prediction of any other matter, and no result is promised.

Fund exit

01 · Preferred-share repurchase under a VIE structure

An offshore fund held preferred shares in a BVI vehicle that held a VIE interest in an internet platform. The repurchase right was triggered by a missed listing deadline. The company had acknowledged the trigger in correspondence but had never convened the shareholders’ meeting that starts a capital reduction.

What was done. The trigger date was fixed from the filing record and the board waiver; notice was re-served with a delivery record; arbitration was commenced in Hong Kong; and a preservation application was filed in the mainland against the operating entity’s accounts and equity. Two individuals had given personal guarantees at the time of investment.

Where it turned. Not on the clause, which was clear, but on the guarantees. The company’s defence — that no reduction had been completed — was a good answer to the claim against the company and no answer at all to the claim against the guarantors. The file settled after the preservation bit.

Fund exit

02 · Consumer e-commerce platform, listing condition missed

An offshore fund held a minority position in a VIE-structured e-commerce group with a repurchase right triggered if an IPO did not close by a fixed date. The amount in dispute was in the tens of millions of US dollars. Three onshore entities shared the operating business, the trademarks and the payment accounts.

What was done. The claim was framed against all three, with the evidence chain built from the group’s own filings and the trademark register. Preservation was sought simultaneously in three courts rather than sequentially, and the arbitration documents were drafted so that the onshore applications could be supported by the same evidence set.

Where it turned. On the payment accounts. Once the accounts were frozen, the operating business could not be financed through them, and the negotiation moved from whether to pay to how much and when.

Fund exit

03 · Cayman holding structure, liability across layers

A fund invested through a Cayman holding company that sat above a Hong Kong subsidiary and a mainland operating company. The claim was in the high tens of millions of US dollars, and the respondent’s case was that the entity which signed the repurchase obligation held no assets.

What was done. The ownership chain was reconstructed from the constitutional documents and the annual filings; the flow of funds from the mainland operating company to the holding layer was traced through intercompany agreements and service fees; and a preservation application was prepared against the mainland entity’s equity in its own subsidiaries.

Where it turned. On the intercompany flow, which supported a claim that the operating company had been used to strip value out of the group rather than simply to trade.

Fund exit

04 · Earn-out dispute in a hardware manufacturer

An institution held a stake in a smart-hardware manufacturer with a repurchase right tied to performance targets. The claim was in the hundreds of millions of RMB. The dispute was not whether the target was missed — the audited accounts showed that it was — but whether adjustments in the accounts were legitimate.

What was done. A forensic reading of three years of management accounts against the audited statements; a schedule of every adjustment above a materiality threshold; and arbitration papers that put each adjustment to the respondent as a separate question of fact. Multi-party preservation followed.

Where it turned. On two adjustments that could not be explained by any accounting policy, which converted a valuation argument into a credibility argument.

Control

05 · Control series inside a private group

A listed company’s subsidiary was in a joint operation with a private group. The group’s founding family controlled the operating entity’s seals, its books and its bank authority, and had moved two contracts to an affiliate. Claims in the series were in the hundreds of millions of RMB.

What was done. An inventory of seals, books and bank mandates was made in the first week; a resolution challenge and a return-of-seals claim were filed; derivative claims were built from the related-party transactions in the books; and preservation was renewed in each round rather than left to lapse.

Where it turned. On the contracts that had been novated to the affiliate: once those were traced, the derivative claim had a number attached to it, and the negotiation had a subject.

Fund exit

06 · Fund exit at the LP/GP layer

A fund’s limited partners sought to exit after the manager missed its own reporting and valuation obligations. The dispute was contractual rather than corporate: partnership agreement terms, the manager’s fiduciary duties, and the valuation basis for an exit.

What was done. The partnership agreement was mapped clause by clause against what had actually been done; a document-production request was issued before any claim was filed; and the valuation dispute was isolated so that the exit mechanics could proceed without waiting for it.

Where it turned. On production. Once the manager’s own reports were on the table, the gap between the stated and actual position was the case.

Enforcement

07 · Award enforced against an operating entity

An award had been obtained in Hong Kong against a mainland distributor. At enforcement, the distributor’s registered assets consisted of a small office and two vehicles. The creditor’s file showed years of payments from three accounts, one of them in the name of a logistics affiliate.

What was done. Enforcement was filed where the accounts operated; receivables from two disclosed counterparties were attached; and the affiliate’s role was tested through a separate claim rather than assumed.

Where it turned. On the receivables. The office and the vehicles produced nothing; the attached receivables produced the majority of the recovery.

Control

08 · Joint venture deadlock, 50:50

A foreign investor held 50 per cent of a manufacturing joint venture; the Chinese partner held the other 50 and, in practice, the seals, the books and the bank tokens. The shareholders’ agreement gave neither party a casting vote and set no deadlock price.

What was done. An inspection claim for the books was filed first, because it was fast and produced facts; the deadlock position was documented for a dissolution petition, which was held rather than filed; and a buyout structure was designed against the valuation produced by the books.

Where it turned. On the books. Once the accounts were produced under an order, the valuation range narrowed enough for both sides to negotiate, and the petition was never filed.

What these notes are for

They are not a track record to be counted. They are a description of where these files actually turn: on the notice, on the accounts, on the guarantee, on the receivables. If a matter you are looking at has one of those features, the notes say what the first three weeks should look like.

Does your file look like one of these?

Send the clause, the trigger document and one page of accounts. The comparison takes a week, not a month.

Make contact