Liang WeiweiPRC counsel · Shanghai
Practice · Fund exit

Exiting a PRC portfolio company when the target will not pay.

The clause is usually not the problem. The problem is that a buyback out of company money is a capital transaction, and the party who controls the procedure controls the timing.

Three gates decide whether an offshore fund recovers anything: whether the right was exercised inside the window, whether the company completed a compliant capital reduction, and whether anyone other than the company is liable. A file that ignores the second gate wins the argument and collects nothing.

What the file actually contains

In a typical mandate the fund holds a minority stake in a PRC operating company, usually through a VIE or a Hong Kong holding layer, with a repurchase right triggered by an IPO long-stop, a revenue or profit target, or a material breach. The controller has signed, in some files, a personal guarantee; in others, only the company is bound. When the trigger fires, the fund serves notice; the company acknowledges, then does nothing; eighteen months later the fund is deciding whether to sue a company whose audited accounts show no distributable assets.

The work is not one lawsuit. It is a sequence: establish the date of the trigger from documents, serve a notice that can be proved, decide the forum, preserve assets before the other side knows a claim exists, and identify the defendants who are not protected by the reduction requirement.

The three gates, in order

GateWhat decides itWhat it costs if missed
The windowThe contract period if it fixes one; otherwise a reasonable period, in practice no more than about six months from the trigger. Proved by the notice and its delivery record.The right itself. A strong claim exercised late is weaker than a thin claim exercised on time.
The reductionBalance sheet, resolution, notice to known creditors, thirty-day announcement, security for objecting creditors, registration of the change.Payment from the company. The claim is refused, not dismissed on the merits.
The partyGuarantees, unpaid contributions, one-person-company status, controller direction of the company to the creditor’s detriment.The recovery. A judgment against an empty company is an expensive document.

What this practice does on a fund exit

  • Reconstructs the trigger date and the notice chain from board minutes, waivers, side letters and email, and states in writing whether the window is open.
  • Designs the forum: HKIAC or SCIA where the clause provides for it, PRC court where it does not, and the preservation application that has to run in parallel on the mainland.
  • Maps the defendants: the company, the controller, the holding vehicle, the guarantors, and any affiliate that received the assets.
  • Prepares the reduction argument in both directions — how to compel it, and how to argue that its absence should not bar the claim against other parties.
  • Prices the recovery honestly: what the claim is worth, what enforcement costs, and what a settlement at 60 cents would look like.

What this practice does not do

  • Give opinions on BVI, Cayman or Hong Kong law. Those are taken from counsel admitted there, and the team works with a Hong Kong chambers on a standing basis.
  • Guarantee a recovery, or predict what a tribunal will do. A view is given on the documents; the outcome is not promised.
  • Act as a mailbox between an offshore client and a PRC subsidiary. If the file needs a decision, the decision is argued.

Timing, realistically

  1. Two weeks: documents read, trigger date and notice position fixed, defendants mapped.
  2. Two to four weeks: notice served, preservation prepared, forum confirmed, budget approved.
  3. Six to twelve months: arbitration or first-instance trial, in a contested file.
  4. Three to nine months after the award: recognition, enforcement, asset tracing, and — where the company has no assets — proceedings against the parties behind it.

Documents to send first

The investment agreement and any side letter or amendment; the shareholders agreement; the trigger document (audited accounts, the IPO filing, the breach notice); the notice of exercise and proof of delivery; the constitutional documents of the offshore chain; the PRC company’s latest filed accounts and credit report; any guarantee or security; and the correspondence in which the company declined to pay. Seven documents, not the data room.

Where this is written

  • Company Law of the PRC (2023), articles 89, 224 and 226 — the buyback right, the reduction procedure, and liability for an unlawful reduction.
  • Minutes of the Ninth National Courts’ Civil and Commercial Trial Work Conference, paragraph 5 — the reduction precondition, and the routes that remain open against other parties.
  • Civil Code of the PRC, articles 577 and 584 — breach and the measure of damages.
  • Arbitration Law of the PRC and the Hong Kong–mainland arrangement on enforcement of arbitral awards, where the clause provides for HKIAC.

Scope: this page states PRC law only. It expresses no view on the law of any other jurisdiction, and no view on any particular file.

Is the window still open?

Send the clause, the trigger document and the notice. That is enough to say whether the first gate has been passed.

Ask about a file